Informational only, not medical advice. Read our disclaimer.
Medicare

Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage: Two Ways to Cap What Medicare Leaves You to Pay

Reviewed by D.P., PharmD.

An older East Asian man with short gray hair and glasses in a navy cardigan reviewing two stacks of paperwork at a bright kitchen table, a pen in hand and a mug of coffee beside him
Key takeaways
  • Original Medicare has no yearly limit on what you pay. Medigap and Medicare Advantage are the two ways to cap those costs; you cannot have both.
  • Medigap pairs with Original Medicare, pays most of what Medicare leaves behind, and lets you see any doctor who takes Medicare anywhere. It does not cover drugs, so you add a separate Part D plan.
  • Medicare Advantage delivers Parts A and B through a private plan. Its limit on in-network medical cost sharing varies by plan and cannot exceed $9,850 in 2027. Premiums and non-covered services are excluded. Most plans bundle drug coverage and use provider networks; prior authorization is common.
  • The timing is one-sided: you can join or switch Medicare Advantage plans every fall, but Medigap's federal open enrollment window lasts six months, starting the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. Other guaranteed issue protections may apply.
Key dates
  • Annual Enrollment Period (AEP): October 15 to December 7. Join, switch, or drop Medicare Advantage and Part D plans; changes take effect January 1.
  • Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment: January 1 to March 31. Only if you are already enrolled in Medicare Advantage: switch to a different Advantage plan or back to Original Medicare once.
  • General Enrollment Period: January 1 to March 31. Missed your initial window? Sign up here; coverage starts the month after.
  • Medigap Open Enrollment Period: six months, one time only. Starts the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B; it does not repeat.

Original Medicare still leaves real bills: the Part A deductible is $1,736 for each hospital benefit period in 2026, and Part B charges 20 percent of most doctor and outpatient services, with no yearly limit. Two products close that gap in opposite ways: Medigap sits on top of Original Medicare and pays what it leaves behind, while Medicare Advantage replaces it.

A common moment at the kitchen table

Two envelopes arrive in the same week: a Medigap quote with a monthly premium, and the Annual Notice of Change from a Medicare Advantage plan, listing copays and an out-of-pocket limit. Both describe the same year of care, in different languages.

The two roads, side by side

Figures are for 2026 unless a 2027 figure is marked. Both routes still require the Part B premium: $202.90 a month in 2026 and $209.40 a month in 2027.

Medicare AdvantageOriginal Medicare plus Medigap
What it isA private plan delivering Parts A and B, usually with Part D built inA supplement that pays most of what Original Medicare leaves behind
Monthly premium beyond Part BOften $0; $14.37 average in 2026, $12.00 projected for 2027Plan G averages $194 a month (2025); $244 across all plans
What you pay for careCopays per visit, up to the yearly limitThe $283 Part B deductible (2026), then Plan G pays nearly everything else
Prescription drugsUsually includedNot included; buy a separate Part D plan
DoctorsA network; referrals and prior authorization commonAny doctor or hospital that takes Medicare, anywhere in the country
TravelEmergency care covered anywhere in the US; routine care usually in-network onlyMost plans cover 80 percent of emergency care abroad, up to a $50,000 lifetime limit
Switching laterJoin or switch every fall during AEPEasy only in your six-month window; health questions after that in most states

How Medigap works

Medigap, also called Medicare Supplement Insurance, is sold by private companies, but the federal government standardizes the coverage. In most states the plans are named by letter, A through N, and the same letter means the same benefits. Medicare.gov puts it plainly: price is the only difference between policies with the same letter.

Plan G is the most popular letter by a wide margin. Mark Farrah Associates reported more than 13.8 million Medigap members at the end of 2025. KFF reported Plan G covered about 6.3 million people, or 46 percent of policyholders. For Medicare-covered services within plan benefit limits, Plan G pays the cost sharing Original Medicare leaves behind except the Part B deductible, including the Part A deductible, 20 percent Part B coinsurance, and Part B excess charges. Plan F also pays the Part B deductible, but it is unavailable to people newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. People eligible before that date may still be able to buy it. Plan N costs less and leaves copays of up to $20 for office visits and up to $50 for emergency room visits. High-deductible Plan G carries the same benefits after you pay $2,950 of Medicare-approved costs in 2026, a figure CMS sets each year, for a much lower premium.

KFF found policyholders paid $244 a month on average in 2025, $2,926 a year, and Plan G averaged $194 a month. Two limits: no Medigap policy sold today covers prescription drugs, so add a separate Part D plan, and a policy covers one person only, so a spouse buys their own.

How Medicare Advantage caps your costs

Medicare Advantage is the more common choice: KFF counted 35.2 million people in it in 2026, about 55 percent of everyone with Medicare. The plan, not Original Medicare, pays your claims, and federal rules require every plan to cap yearly spending on covered Part A and B services. CMS caps the limit a plan may choose at $9,850 for in-network care in 2027, and $14,800 combined for PPO plans. Plans may set a lower limit, so your plan's own number is the one that applies.

The premium is the small number and the limit is the large one. The average Medicare Advantage premium is $14.37 a month in 2026, and CMS projects $12.00 a month in 2027, with many plans charging $0 beyond the Part B premium. Most plans bundle Part D, whose out-of-pocket cap, $2,100 in 2026 and $2,400 in 2027, sits on top of the plan's medical limit. The trade for the low premium is control: networks, and usually prior authorization. KFF found plans denied about 12 percent of prior authorization requests, and about two-thirds of appealed denials were overturned. That is not two-thirds of all denials.

The one window that changes everything

The biggest difference between the two roads is the calendar, not the premium or the network. Your Medigap Open Enrollment Period lasts six months, starting the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During those six months, any Medigap insurer in your state has to sell you any policy it offers, with no health questions and no higher price for poor health. Medicare.gov calls this the best time to buy; the window is one-time and does not come back next fall.

After the window closes, the rules flip in most states: an insurer can ask health questions, charge more, or turn you down, unless a guaranteed issue right applies. Four states, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine, and New York, require insurers to sell Medigap to people 65 and older regardless of health. One trial right covers the first year: join a Medicare Advantage plan when first eligible at 65, leave within 12 months, and you can return to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap policy with guaranteed issue rights. KFF found that 74 percent of Medicare Advantage enrollees, 20.9 million people in 2023, had a pre-existing condition that could cost them a Medigap policy after that trial period.

The other direction is easy: you can move from Medigap to Medicare Advantage in any fall enrollment period, and the plan has to take you. The harder direction can be Advantage back to Medigap after the first year: underwriting may apply, unless a federal or state protection applies.

A year of costs, side by side

The two routes trade a steady premium for a variable bill. In a healthy year with a few doctor visits and no hospital stay, a $0 premium Medicare Advantage plan might cost a few hundred dollars in copays, while Plan G at the $194 national average costs $2,328 for the year plus the $283 Part B deductible, with a Part D premium on top.

In a bad year with a hospital stay and months of specialists, the picture reverses. On the Advantage route, copays add up until the plan's out-of-pocket limit, up to the limit stated in that plan's coverage documents. With standard Plan G, the 2026 Part B deductible is $283; other covered Part A and B cost sharing is paid within plan benefit limits. Covered Part D drugs have a separate $2,100 out-of-pocket cap in 2026. Premiums and non-covered services are not included in those caps. This is an illustration using national averages, not a quote. Price your own year by running your drugs and pharmacy through Medicare Plan Compare.

What to check before December 7

The Annual Enrollment Period closes December 7 for coverage starting January 1, 2027. Before it passes, check four things: are your doctors and hospital in the plan's network for 2027, not just 2026; does its drug list cover your prescriptions; what is the plan's own out-of-pocket limit; and, if you are 65 or older and newly on Part B, is your six-month Medigap window still open? It starts the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, not on the fall enrollment calendar. Your state's SHIP program offers free one-on-one help. Our total cost guide shows how to compare on the full year's cost.

What this means while enrollment is open

Medigap and Medicare Advantage answer the same problem, that Original Medicare has no yearly limit, in opposite ways: one charges a steady premium and leaves almost nothing variable, the other charges little up front and caps the variable part. Neither is the low-cost choice in every year, so compare on total yearly cost, not the premium alone. If your Medigap window is open, it is the one decision here with a deadline that does not repeat. Check it before December 7.

Not medical advice.

This guide explains how Medigap and Medicare Advantage work, what each costs, and when you can buy each one. It doesn't advise which coverage to choose, doesn't recommend any plan or product, and doesn't advise starting, stopping, or switching any medication or treatment. Those decisions belong to you, your doctor, and your pharmacist. Premiums, limits, and enrollment rules change every year and vary by state and plan, so confirm the current figures with Medicare.gov, your state insurance department, or your local SHIP program before enrolling. For personal guidance, use Medicare Plan Compare or contact your local SHIP program. Full disclaimer.

Sources